Prefer to watch this case on YouTube? Watch here
For this case, we are travelling back to 1923, to the Savoy Hotel London. On the night of a thunderous storm that rocked the city, following a loud and raucous argument, a wife shoots her husband dead. She is discovered with the gun in her hand and admitted to the murder immediately. She committed the crime, no doubt about it. Then how was she found not guilty at trial?
This case has it all, privilege, money, royalty and affairs.
So let’s get into what led up to that deadly night at the Savoy.
Marguerite Marie Alibert was born on 9th December 1890, the eldest daughter of Firmin Alibert, a coachman and Marie Aurand, a housekeeper in Paris, France. While the family were poor Marguerite got a peek into the Parisian Elite through the families her parents worked for. An elite she would strive to join thought her youth.
When she was 15 tragedy struck the family, when while under Marguerite’s care her 4-year-old brother was hit by a lorry, the accident was fatal. Her parents held her personally responsible for the little boy’s death, and as a punishment she was sent to the Sisters of Mary boarding school. Where she was subjected to regular physical and emotional abuse. Although she didn’t receive much formal education, she did develop a lovely singing voice, excellent social skills and a strong-willed nature.
At 16 she was thrown out when she fell pregnant after a short spell as a domestic maid in a local house. The father was never revealed. She gave birth to a baby girl Raymonde, to escape the stigma that having a child out of wedlock carried at the time she sent her daughter to be raised by family on a farm in the French countryside.
Not being able to return home, Marguerite was forced to fend for herself leading to a short spell as a lady of the night on the streets of Paris. Her natural beauty and grace caught the eye of a local brothel Madame Denant who took her under her wing.
She soon became a popular courtesan attracting the rich and powerful of Parisian society. The high-class sex industry in Paris at that time was very glamorous. Brothels were ornately decorated places where beautiful women played out the fantasies of men from around the world.
When she was 17, in 1907 she met Andre Meller a 40-year-old Wine Merchant who owned a stable full of horses. He purchased her an apartment where they could conduct their relationship in private. Marguerite took his name and told everyone they were married. In truth, Andre was already married. The relationship ended in 1913. She received 2 hundred thousand francs from Andre when they separated. It was through this relationship that she realised she could make a lucrative income from seducing rich men.
Marguerite had risen through the ranks of the Parisian courtesan scene and was now a very successful and desirable companion and in 1917 she was formally introduced to Edward the Prince of Wales. Eventually, Edward would be the king who abdicated to marry Wallace Simpson. He was in France serving as an officer in the Grenadier Guards, on the western front of World War One. The introduction was made by 2 of his friends after concluding that 23-year-old Edward required “a full education from an experienced woman”. Edward was instantly infatuated with the beautiful and sophisticated Marguerite. They began an intense and passionate affair. He would visit her at every opportunity his duties allowed. Edward also wrote to Marguerite long and spicy letters declaring his love and desires for her. He also wrote some rather disparaging comments about his father King George the 5th and disclosed information about the progress of the British forces’ war effort. Within the year, Edward began to lose interest. Marguerite was a smart woman and of course, insisted on a generous severance package now her services were no longer required. And most importantly she kept his letters as an insurance policy of sorts should she ever need it.
Marguerite married for the first time in 1919 to Charles Laurent a wealthy young airman. He legally adopted Raymonde and they both took his last name – finally, they were both free of the stigma of illegitimacy. However, it was not to last and the marriage ended within 6 months. She received an enormous lifetime settlement.
She was now a woman of independent means, at only 30. She owned an impressive property on Avenue Henri-Martin, stable of horses employed servants and had cars to transport her as she wished. She was able to reunite with Raymonde and send her to a fantastic boarding school in England. Marguerite had achieved the high-class lifestyle for which she had strived. But that didn’t mean she had stopped pursuing potential new suitors.
Marguerite met Prince Ali Kamel Fahmy Bey, a very wealthy businessman in 1921 during a trip to Eygpt. She was escorting another businessman at the time but that didn’t stop her from making sure to catch his eye. He was infatuated.
Ali Kamel Fahmy wasn’t technically a Prince in the way Edward was, but due to his wealth, he was given the title “Bey” which is like Lord or Governor and entitled him to claim royal status.
They official met in 1922 and a proposal soon followed. Along with an invitation to live in Cairo. Marguerite was hesitant but did agree. I believe for her this was another pathway to Ali’s money and not a marriage based on love and affection. It was a negotiation from the beginning. She was to convert to Islam and in return 2 clauses were added to the marriage contract. 1. She could wear western clothing 2. That she could divorce him. However, she was double-crossed and just before the wedding the divorce clause was removed and one allowing Ali to take extra wives was added. They were married in December 1922 followed by a formal Islamic wedding in January 1923.
There could not have been a more mismatched couple and it made for a very volatile relationship. Ali expected a submissive and obedient wife consistent with Islamic culture something the strong-willed, wildly independent and sexually experienced Marguerite could not conform to. He was often deeply embarrassed by her behaviour, especially during public arguments.
Ali did not trust Marguerite and he had his houseboy observe her, and would frequently beat her. It is here that it begins to look like she is building a case of abuse to force a divorce.
On Sunday 1st July 1923 Prince and Princess Fahmy arrived at the Savoy Hotel London.
A few nights into their stay she called the Savoy’s Doctor under the pretence of having haemorrhoids treated but once alone with him confided in him that she had been injured during a none consensual sex act Ali had insisted on. She asked the Doctor to document her injuries and to certify that they existed should her husband dispute her claims. There have been rumours in Egypt that Ali was actually gay so accusations from a western wife that he had forced anal sex on her would have been devastating for his reputation. Given the society’s attitude to homosexuality and that it was still a criminal offence. The Doctor declined to make any record.
On the night of the 9th of July, the couple attended the Daly’s Theatre on Cranbourne Street to see the eerily prophetic play “The Merry Widow” before returning to Savoy restaurant for a late supper. The meal was cut short when yet another argument broke out.
These were now a daily occurrence and becoming more nasty and physical. Ali was reported to have scratches on his neck and Marguerite bruises on her face that she tried to cover with make-up.
Eventually, they were calmed down and retired to the Ballroom to listen to the Havana Band. Again this didn’t last long and after refusing to dance with Ali, Marguerite returned to their suite. Ali decided to leave the hotel, despite being in full formal evening dress and the weather beginning to turn into a violent storm. He headed towards Piccadilly, it was assumed to find an illegal nightclub to attend.
At around 2 am the hotel’s night porter passed the couple’s suite door when he witnessed Ali whistling to their pet dog that had been following the porter down the corridor. He walked a few more steps down the hall when he heard 3 shots all fired in quick succession. Running into the suite he saw Marguerite drop a black handgun and Ali slumped over with wounds to his neck, back and head. The hotel manager was summoned and Marguerite remarked to him “Oh, sir, I have been married 6 months, which has been torture for me. I have suffered terribly”
Ali was taken to Charing Cross Hospital but died of his wounds within the hour.
Marguerite was arrested for murder, Percival Clarke was the prosecutor. He considered it an open and shut case and that she would soon be behind bars or maybe face the gallows.
The trial began on the 10th of September 1923 and lasted 5 days. Coincidentally Prince Edward was due to fill royal duties in the UK that week but was unexpectedly sent to Canada.
Sir Edward Marshall Hall and Sir Henry Curtis- Bennett were Marguerite’s defence. It was in 2 parts:
- Marguerite’s version of events that night. She alleged that Ali had tried to strangle her that evening and that he had pulled the gun on her. In the struggle that ensued the gun fired 3 times. Admitting she had shot him but claiming it was self-defence.
- The outright assassination of Ali’s character and culture. This involved Hall crouching, snarling and hissing imitating the animalistic and murderous Ali. Even pointing the gun at the jury to demonstrate the scene Marguerite was faced with. He played into all of society’s prejudices about Eastern culture and even went as far as to accuse Ali and his male private secretary of being intimate. Ali was described as “a monster of Eastern depravity and decadence, whose sexual tastes were indicative of an amoral sadism towards his helpless European wife”
As well as being shocking this type of defence was risky. Court rules meant that if the victim’s past and character were questioned it opened the door for the same to be done to the accused. Yet the judge Mr Justice Rigby Swift ruled several times that Marguerite’s past could not be discussed in court. So the jury didn’t know about her sex work, her previous divorce and most importantly Prince Edward. Her affair with him could not be discussed. She presented herself on the stand as a devoted Muslim wife.
The only physical evidence that supported the defence version of events was a medical report from an examination of Marguerite when at Holloway Prison. Three abrasions on her neck were observed by the doctor and concluded to have been caused by a man’s hand.
The prosecutor presented the porter’s eye witness statement, that there was no fight preceding the shooting. And that the gun a 0.32 Browning pistol could not have been accidentally fired 3 times. That model of gun needed the trigger to be deliberately pulled for each shot fired. Meaning Marguerite’s version of events could not have been what happened.
The jury deliberated for less than an hour. Marguerite was acquitted of both murder and manslaughter. She left the court a completely free woman.
It caused a sensation in England and throughout Europe. Even in 1923 Hall was criticised for the lurid way he had described Ali and as the wider public began to learn more about Princess Marguerite public opinion swayed against her.
In the years since the trial, there has been much speculation about Prince Edward and his advisor’s role in the outcome of the trial. Had Marguerite cashed in her insurance policy? Offering to return the letters for her freedom. In my opinion, this is what happened a deal was struck to keep her past including Edward out of court not sure I would go as far as saying the jury was bought. Please let me know what you think happened?
Not content with the outcome Marguerite sued Ali’s family to lay a claim to the property and assets of her late husband. The Egyptian court rejected the English verdict and dismissed her claim but she was allowed to keep the title.
Princess Marguerite returned to Paris, living in an apartment opposite the Ritz and continuing her lavish lifestyle. She passed away aged 80. After her death, her grandson discovered that she was still receiving 5 money settlements from previous lovers.
